A study of Vitamin-D and nutritional status in recurrent respiratory tract infections in children 1-5 years of age

Ruhi A. ¹, Ananth T.²

¹Dr. ApsiaRuhi, Resident, Department of Endocrinology, Gandhi Medical College, Secunderabad, Telangana, India. ²Dr. Tudumu Ananth, 1.             Associate Professor, Department of Paediatrics, Bhaskar Medical College, Yenkapally, Moinabad, Ranga Reddy District, Telangana, India.

Corresponding Author: Tudumu Ananth, Associate Professor, Department of Paediatrics, Bhaskar Medical College, Yenkapally, Moinabad, Ranga Reddy District, Telangana, India. E-mail: drananthbmc@gmail.com

Abstract

Objective:To assess and explore the association of Vitamin D deficiency with recurrent respiratory tract infections in children less than 5 years.Design:This wasa prospective non-randomized two group design study.

Duration:One year and four months, i.e. July 2015 to October 2016.Setting:Department of Pediatrics, Bhaskar Medical College, Telangana, India.Participants:90 children, all aged less than 5 years, attendingthe Department of Pediatrics, Bhaskar Medical College.Methods:Out of total 90 cases, 50 children with recurrent respiratory tract Infections (RRTI)were taken as Group I, while 40 children without recurrent respiratory tract Infections were taken as Group II. After thorough clinical examination, Serum Vitamin D levels were estimatedby Radio Immune Assay (RIA) technique. Statistical analysis was done using appropriate software.Results: Serum Vitamin D levels ranged from 20 to 140 nmol/l. It was depicted that 86% of children with recurrent respiratory tract infections had Vitamin D deficiency.Vitamin D deficiency and number of respiratory tract infections are more in male children. The mean Vitamin D level in Group I (RRTI) was low i.e. 41.7 nmol/I compared to 64.6 nmo1/1 in Group 11 (no RRTI). Vitamin D deficiency and number of respiratory tract infections were more in the 37-48 months age group. Vitamin D levels were low in children who were exclusively breast fed for 6 months (47%). Vitamin D levels were low in children who had poor exposure to sunlight (79%).Conclusion:There was a significant association between Vitamin D levels and recurrent respiratory tract infections. Education regarding the importance and timing of sun exposure is necessary. Routine Vitamin D supplementation is recommended.

Key words:Vitamin D Deficiency, Respiratory Tract Infections, Children, Recurrent.

Manuscript received: 5th April 2019 Reviewed: 16th April 2019 

Author Corrected: 21st April 2019 Accepted for Publication: 26th April 2019

Introduction

The role of diet in the development of rickets was determined by Edward Mellany between1918-1920[1] .In 1921, ELMER Mc Collum identified an anti-rachitic substance found in certainfats could prevent rickets [2]. Because the newly discovered substance was the fourth Vitaminidentified, it was called D Vitamin.Vitamin D deficiency is considered to be the mostcommon nutritional deficiency. Vitamin D is a group of fat soluble pro-hormones, the twomajor forms of which are vitamin D2 (or ergocalciferol) and vitamin D3 (orcholecalciferol).Vitamin D is crucial for musculoskeletal development. The mainfunction of vitamin D in the body is to regulate calcium and phosphorous homeostasis, aprocess essential for bone mineralization [3]. Vitamin D also required for the contraction ofmuscles, nerve conduction and functioning of all cells of the body [4].In India sub clinical vitamin D deficiency is wide spread in all age groups.Vitamin D can be obtained from sunlight exposure and diet. Since few foods contain vitamin D, sunlight exposure is theprimary determinant of vitamin D status in humans[5].The amount of Vitamin D from sun differswith skincolour, season and pollution[6]. Dietary intakes of both calcium and vitamin D are verylow in majority of population except in high socioeconomic groups [7].The concentration ofVitamin D must be interpreted in the context of season, as higher concentrations areobserved during summer months [8].People living at high altitudes are more prone to seasonalVitamin D deficiency as in winter, this is possibly because winter time sunlight does notpromote conversion of Vitamin D precursors in skin[9].In recent years, a wide variety ofconditions such as autoimmune diseases, cardiovascular diseases, cancers, type 2 diabeteshave also been shown to be associated with vitamin D deficiency[10]. Vitamin D is foundnaturally in very few foods. Foods containing Vitamin D include some fatty fish (mackerel,salmon, sardines), and fish liver oils, egg yolk. Other sources of Vitamin D include fortifiedfoods particularly dairy products and some cereals.Lack of sunlight exposure, outdooractivity in sun, poor vitamin D intake are associated factors for its deficiency[11]. Milk from themothers whose diet is sufficient and properly balanced will supply all the necessary nutrients except fluoride and vitamin D[12]. Concentration of vitamin D is 0.5-101U/100m1 of breastmilk. Pediatric respiratory tract infections are one of the most common reasons for physicianvisits and hospitalization, and are associated with significant morbidity and mortality.Respiratory infections are common and frequent diseases and present one of the majorcomplaints in children. Recurrent throat problems in children are common and have animpact on the family. Time off school or parental time off work was significantly associatedwith parental worry and disruption. This study is intended to evaluate the possibleassociation of vitamin D deficiency and nutritional status with recurrent respiratory infectionsin children aged less than five years. The aim of the study is to study the association ofvitamin D deficiency with recurrent respiratory tract infections in children less than 5 years.To assess Vitamin D levels and nutritional status in recurrent respiratory tract infections,explore the association between Vitamin D deficiency and recurrent respiratory tractinfections and to study prevalence of Vitamin D in children less than 5 years.

Materials and Methods

Place of Study:Department of Pediatrics, Bhaskar Medical College, Yenkapally, Moinabad, Raga Reddy District, Telangana, India.

Type of Study:This was a prospective non-randomized two group design study.

Sample Collection:All patients aged less than 5 years with and without recurrent respiratory tract infections attending the outpatient department or admitted as inpatient in the Department of Pediatrics,Bhaskar Medical College who fulfill the inclusion criteria were included in the study. About 3 ml of blood was collected and sent for serum 25 (OH) vitamin D analysis.

Sampling Methods:This study is designed to detect a difference of at least 40% in the prevalence of vitamin deficiency between cases and controls. In order to detect this difference at 5% level of significance an 90% power of the test the minimum sample required is 36 per group. In order to reach a set of 72 evaluate children (cases and controls) we targeted 90 patients after factoring anticipated dropouts and patients who will not consent to participate. Serum 25(OH)D levels were measured by Radio Immune Assay(RIA).

Inclusion Criteria

1. Children between 1 month to 5 years of age

2. Children with symptoms of recurrent respiratory tract infections.

Exclusion Criteria

1. Children less than 1 month of age and greater than 5 years of age.

2. Children with congenital heart disease.

3. Recipients of massive dose of Vitamin D supplementation within last 4 weeks.

Statistical Methods:Statistical analysis was done using appropriate software.

Results

A total of 90 children were considered for study during the study period. Out of total 90 cases, 50 children with recurrent respiratory tract infections were taken as group I, while 40 children without recurrent respiratory tract infections (RRTI) were taken as Group II.

Table-1: Vitamin D levels Vs RRTI

OR: odds ratio, CI: confidence interval, ** : highly significant, *: not significant

In Group I (RRTI), 86% (43) children had vitamin D deficiency whereas, in Group II (no RRTI), 35 %( 14) had vitamin D deficiency having vitamin D deficiency increases the odds of RRTI by 11 times (the risk in increased by 11 times).

Table-2: Vitamin D mean (SD) among studied groups

P-value <0.01: Highly Significant

In addition to the above analysis, mean values of vitamin D were compared between the two groups. The mean value of vitamin D for Group I (RRTI) was 41.7 compared to Group II 64.6(no RRTI). There is a highly significant positive correlation between vitamin D and RRTI group.

Table-3: Exclusive breast feeding V/s Vitamin D among the studied Groups

OR: odds ratio, CI: confidence interval, ^**: highly significant,^*: not significant, ^#: Yates

correction

In Group I (RRTI), Vitamin D was deficient in 53% of childrenwho had not received exclusive breast feeding for 6 months whereas in Group II(no RRTI) 93% were Vitamin D deficient in non-exclusive breast feeding

Table-4: H/o Sunlight Exposure v/s Vitamin D among the studied Groups

OR: odds ratio, CI: confidence interval, ^**: highly significant,^*: not significant, ^#: Yates

Correction

79% of Group I (RRTI) 93% of Group II (no RRTI) who were not exposed to sunlight had vitamin D deficiency.

Table-5: Number of patients with deficient and normal vitamin D levels in different RRTIs

Among 50 cases in group 1 with RRTI 44 children (88%) are vitamin deficient.

Among 50 cases in group 1 with RRTI 44 children (12%) are vitamin D deficient and most of the bronchopneumonia and HRAD patients had the deficiency.

Discussion

The association between Vitamin D levels and susceptibility to recurrent respiratory tract infections was studied in children less than 5 years. Serum 25-hydroxy Vitamin D levels were measured in children with recurrent respiratory tract infections as well as in healthy, similar age group without history of respiratory tract infections. In our study, there were insignificant differences between Group I (RRTI) and Group II (no RRTI) regarding age, gender and site of residence to explain the low levels of Vitamin D in the group l(RRTI). Similarly study done by Albannaet.al, also showed no significant difference between cases and controls regarding socio demographic variables. In a another similar study done by Wayse et.a1[13] with 80 cases and 70 controls there was no significant difference between cases and controls with age distribution(P-value=0.09) similarly the study didn't find any significance in the proportion of children in cases and controls pertaining to other socio demographic variables.

The main finding of our study was that serum 25-hydroxy Vitamin D concentrations in the Group I( RRTI) was significantly lower than those in the Group II( no RRTI). In Group 1 (RRTI), 86% had Vitamin D deficiency where as in Group II (no RRTI) 35% which is comparable to Wayseet.al[13] (80% and 31%), Roth et.al[14] (84% and 60%), and little higher percentage of deficiency was found in Karatekin[15] i.e. 92% in group I and 80% in group II.

Mean Vitamin D Levels- Mean value of Vitamin D was low 41.7 in Group I (RRT1) compared to 64.6 in Group II (no RRTI) which is comparable with Wayse et.al[13](22.8 and 38.4), Roth[14] et.al48(29.1 and 39.1) and Karatekins[15](22.8 and 40.8). There is a significant correlation was found between Vitamin D deficiency and RRTI group (P-value= <0.001)

Sex Distribution- In our study, there were no significant differences in the Vitamin D deficiency between males and females (P-value = 0.91) similar to Nighathaideret.a1[16] study.

Age Distribution-In our study, there were no significant differences with Vitamin D deficiency with respiratory tract infections between the age groups 1month-5 years. In contrast to our study WAYSE[13] et.al 47 showed that serum 25-hydroxyVitaminD levels increase significantly with age (P-value < 0.001).However, Nighathaider et al[16] in their study of 137 children with respiratory tract infections showed that highest incidence of Vitamin D deficiency was found in age group of 2-12 months (79.8%).

Exclusive Breast Feeding- Vitamin D deficiency was seen (47%) in exclusively breastfed infants for 6 months. No significant association was found between exclusive breast feeding and Vitamin D deficiency in recurrent respiratory tract infections (F-value = 0.91). However, in another study done by Nighathaideret.a1 [16], Vitamin D deficiency was more common in breast fed infants i.e. 85%

Sun Exposure- 79% of Vitamin D deficiency was seen in children who were not exposed to sunlight and only in 21% cases Vitamin D was deficient even with adequate sun exposure (P-value=0.96) which is comparable to a study done by Nighathaider et.al[16], which showed Vitamin D deficiency is more common in children who were not exposed to sunlight(98.3%).

Conclusions

This study showed that 86% of children with recurrent respiratory tract infections had Vitamin D deficiency. Vitamin D deficiency and number of respiratory tract infections are more in male children than female children. The mean Vitamin D level in Group I (RRTI) was low 41.7 nmol/I compared to 64.6 nmo1/1 in Group 11 (no RRTI). Vitamin D deficiency and number of respiratory tract infections are more in the 37-48 months age group followed by 13-24 months age. Vitamin D levels were low in children who were exclusively breast fed for 6 months (47%). Vitamin D levels were low in children who had poor exposure to sunlight (79%). There is a need for prospective randomized trials in this field to establish cause effect relation between Vitamin D and RRTI. Education regarding the importance and timing of sun exposure should be done (1/2 hour a day for 5-6 day/week bet. 10 am to 3 pm). As most of the children are deficient in serum Vitamin D levels, routine Vitamin D supplementation may be recommended from birth onwards.

References